Trust, Testimony, and the Epistemic Value of Historical Narrative
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15848/hh.v18.2336Palavras-chave:
Epistemology, Narrativism, TestimonyResumo
A significant contribution of narrativist philosophy of history (whether analytical, phenomenological, or poststructuralist) lies in its critique of relying solely on "strictly" epistemic criteria to evaluate historical narratives. Rather than assessing them based on empirical evidence alone, which is often seen as neutral and value-free, narrativism calls for a broader perspective. This is because no description of people and their behavior can be value-neutral. Narrativism thus aligns with constructivist theories of linguistic meaning, linked to the "linguistic turn." I propose a dialogue between narrativism and the epistemology of testimony. By adopting the latter's concepts (trust, authority, and epistemic community), narrativism can 1) reconstruct practices of epistemic validation in history and 2) address the historian’s responsibility to marginalized voices. Simultaneously, I argue that the epistemology of testimony should engage with narrativism to better understand the complexity of narrative constructions in epistemic communities.
Downloads
Referências
AHLSKOG, Jonas. The Primacy of Method in Historical Research. Philosophy of History and the Perspective of Meaning. London and New York: Routledge. 2021.
AHLSKOG, Jonas. R. G. Collingwood and the Concept of Testimony: A Story about Autonomy and Reliance. Clio: Journal of Literature, History and the Philosophy of History. Fort Wayne, v. 45, n 2, 2016. p. 181-204.
ANKERSMIT, Frank. Historical Representation. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2001.
AUERBACH, Erich. Mimesis: The Representation of Reality in Western Literature. Fiftieth anniversary printing. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2003.
AUERBACH, Erich. Figura. In AUERBACH, Erich. Scenes from the Drama of European Literature. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1984. p. 11-76.
CARR, David. Time, Narrative, and History. Bloomington, Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1986.
CHICO, Juan. Las voces de Napalpí. Resistencia: ConTexto Libros, 2016.
COADY, Cecil Anthony John. Testimony: A Philosophical Study Oxford: Oxford University Press. 1994.
COLLINGWOOD, Robin George. The Idea of History, revised ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 1993.
COLLINGWOOD, An Autobiography. Oxford: Clarendon Press. 1978.
DANTO, Arthur. Narrative Sentences. History and Theory. Middletown, v. 2, n. 2, p. 146-179, 1962. (Included in DANTO, Arthur. Narration and Knowledge. New York: Columbia University Press, 1985. p. 143-181).
DORAN, Robert. Hayden White and the Ethics of Historiography. In DORAN, Robert, The Ethics of Historiography. London: Bloomsbury. 2017. p. 114-123.
FRICKER Miranda. Epistemic Injustice and the Ethics of Knowing, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.
HACKING, Ian. Rewriting the Soul. Multiple Personality and the Sciences of Memory, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995.
HACKING, Ian. The Social Construction of What? Cambridge, London: Harvard University Press, 1999.
JASINSKI, Alejandro. Napalpí, contra el olvido. El cohete a la luna. April 17th. 2022a Disponível em: https://www.elcohetealaluna.com/napalpi-contra-el-olvido/. Acesso em: 11 dez. 2024.
JASINSKI, Alejandro, 1924. Napalpí y la república negadora. Un expediente judicial como estrategia de poder. Contenciosa. Revista sobre violencia política, represiones y resistencias en la historia iberoamericana. n 12. 2022b. https://portal.amelica.org/ameli/journal/607/6073558008/html/. Acesso em: 11 dez. 2024.
KUSCH, Martin. Testimony and the Value of Knowledge. In HADDOCK, Adrian; MILLAR, Alan; Pritchard, Duncan (org.). Epistemic Value, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009. p. 60-94.
KUUKKANEN, Jouni-Matti. Postnarrativist Philosophy of Historiography. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2015.
LA GRECA, María Inés. With or Against Hayden White? Reflections on Theory of History and Subject Formation. History and Theory. Middletown, v. 63, n. 1, 2024. p. 25-44.
LA GRECA, María Inés. Narrative. Bloomsbury History: Theory and Method, London: Bloomsbury, 2021. p. 1-22.
LA GRECA, María Inés. Hayden White and Joan W. Scott's Feminist History: the practical past, the political present and an open future. Rethinking History, The Journal of Theory and Practice. London. v. 20, n. 3, 2016 p. 395-413.
LA GRECA, María Inés. The Future of Philosophy of History from its Narrativist Past: Figuration, Middle Voice Writing and Performativity. Journal of the Philosophy of History. Leiden, v. 8, n., 2014 p. 196-216.
LA GRECA, María Inés. Narrative Trouble, or Hayden White´s Desire for a Progressive Historiography Refigured by Judith Butler´s Performativity Theory. Storia della Storiografia. Pisa, Roma. v. 65, n. 1, 2014 p. 117-130.
LA GRECA, María Inés. Historical Narrative as Performative Structuration. Metatheoria. Buenos Aires. v. 4, n. 1, 2013 p. 55-76.
MCMYLER, Benjamin. Testimony, Trust, and Authority, New York: Oxford University Press, 2011.
MARTINI, María de los Ángeles. Embodied Boundaries of Historical Studies of Science: A Vision of Steven Shapin’s Historiography. In CONDE, Mauro; ́ SALOMON, Marlon (org.). Handbook for the Historiography of Science. Cham: Springer. 2023. p. 189-207.
MEAD, George Herbert. The Present as the Locus of Reality. In MEAD, George Herbert. The Philosophy of the Present. Amherst, New York: Prometheus Book. 2002. p. 35-60.
MINK, Louis. Narrative Form as a Cognitive Instrument. In MINK, Louis. [FAY, Brian, GOLOB, Eugene, VANN, Richard (org.)]. Historical Understanding. (org.) New York: Cornell University Press. 1987. p. 182-203.
MUSANTE Marcelo. Las reducciones estatales indígenas. ¿Espacios concentracionarios o avance del proyecto civilizatorio? VII Jornadas Santiago Wallace de Investigación en Antropología Social. Sección de Antropología Social. Instituto de Ciencias Antropológicas. Facultad de Filosofía y Letras, UBA, Buenos Aires. 2013.
PEREZ, Moira. Violencia epistémica: reflexiones entre lo invisible y lo ignorable. Caseros, El lugar sin límites. Revista de Estudios y Políticas de Género. v. 1, n. 1, 2019. p. 81-98.
PIHLAINEN, Kalle. The Work of History. Constructivism and a Politics of the Past. New York: Routledge. 2017.
POPPER, Karl. The Logic of Scientific Discovery. London and New York: Routledge, 2022.
RICOEUR, Paul. Time and Narrative, Vol 1. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press. 1983.
RIGNEY, Ann. 2016. Cultural Memory Studies: Mediation, narrative, and the aesthetic. In Routledge International Handbook of Memory Studies. TOTA, Anna Lisa; HAGEN, Trever (org.) London and New York: Routledge. P. 65-76.
ROTH, Paul. The Philosophical Structure of Historical Explanation. Evanston: Northwestern University Press. 2020.
SCHUTZ, Alfred (auth.), NATANSON, Maurice (eds.). “Concept and Theory Formation in the Social Sciences”. In SCHUTZ, Alfred, Collected Papers I: The Problem of Social Reality. The Hague: Springer Netherlands, 1972. P. 48-66.
SHAPIN, Stephen. Science and Prejudice in Historical Perspective. In SHAPIN, Stephen. Never Pure. Historical Studies of Science as if It Was Produced by People with Bodies, Situated in Time, Space, Culture, and Society, and Struggling for Credibility and Authority. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press. 2010. p. 47-56.
SHAPIN, Stephen. A Social History of Truth. Civility and Science in Seventeenth-Century England. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press. 1994.
TOZZI THOMPSON Verónica. Historical Irrealism. Paul A. Roth and the Epistemic Value of Narrative Explanation. Review of The Philosophical Structure of Historical Explanation, by Paul A. Roth Rethinking History, The Journal of Theory and Practice. London, v. 27, n. 1. 2023. p. 144-157.
TOZZI THOMPSON, Verónica. Narrativism. In VAN DEN AKKER, Chiel (org.). The Routledge Companion to Historical Theory. London and New York: Routledge. 2021. p. 113-128.
TOZZI THOMPSON, Verónica; PENELAS, Federico. El patrón narrativo de la investigación. La Nueva Filosofía de la Historia a la luz del pragmatismo de John Dewey, Análisis. Revista de investigación filosófica. Universidad de Zaragoza, v. 9, n. 2. 2022. p. 381-405.
TOZZI THOMPSON, Verónica. A pragmatist view on two accounts of the practical nature of our “connection” with the past. Hayden White and David Carr, 30 years later. Rethinking History, The Journal of Theory and Practice, London, Vol. 22, No 1. 2018a. p. 65-85.
TOZZI THOMPSON, Verónica. Hans Kellner, cuatro décadas getting the story crooked. Páginas de Filosofía. Comahue, v. XX, n. 23, 2018b. p. 92-115.
TOZZI, Verónica. Hayden White and Conversational Pluralism. Storia e Storiografia, Turin. v. 65, n. 1. 2014. p. 171-182.
VAN DEN AKKER, Chiel. The Exemplifying Past. A Philosophy of History. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. 2018.
WHITE, Hayden. The Ethics of Narrative. Essays on History and Literature and Theory 1998-2007. Robert Doran (org.) Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. 2022.
WHITE, Hayden. Figura and Historical Subalternation [2000]. In WHITE, Hayden. 2022. p. 84-94.
WHITE, Hayden. Symbols and Allegories of Temporality [1998]. In WHITE, Hayden. 2022. p. 15-32.
WHITE, Hayden. The Historical Event. Differences: A Journal of Feminist Cultural Studies. Providence, v. 19, n 2, 2008. p. 9-34. (Included in WHITE, Hayden. The Practical Past. Evanston: Northwestern University Press. 2014. p. 41-62.
WHITE, Hayden. What Is a Historical System? In Breck, Allen D., Yourgrau, Wolfgang (org). Biology, History, and Natural Philosophy. New York: Plenum Press. 1972. P. 233-242 (Included in WHITE, Hayden. The Fiction of Narrative. Essays on History and Literature and Theory 1957-2007. Robert Doran (org.). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. 2010).
WHITE, Hayden. The Fiction of Narrative. Essays on History and Literature and Theory 1957-2007. Robert Doran (org.). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. 2010.
WHITE, Hayden. Figural Realism. Studies in the Mimesis Effect. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press. 1999.
WHITE, Hayden. Literary Theory and Historical Writing. Figural Realism. Studies in the Mimesis Effect. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press. 1999. p. 1-26.
WHITE, Hayden. Auerbach´s Literary History. Figural Causation and Modernist Historicism. Figural Realism. Studies in the Mimesis Effect. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press. 1999. p. 87-100.
WHITE, Hayden. The Burden of History. History and Theory. Middletown, v. 5, n. 2, 1966. p. 25-44 (Included in WHITE, Hayden. Tropics of Discourse. Essays in Cultural Criticism. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.1978).
WHITE, Hayden. Metahistory. The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press. 1973.
ZAKAI, Avihu and WENSTEIN, David. Erich Auerbach and His ‘Figura’: An Apology for the Old Testament in an Age of Aryan Philology. Religions. Basel, v. 3, 2012. p. 320-338.
Downloads
Publicado
Como Citar
Edição
Seção
Licença
Copyright (c) 2025 Verónica Tozzi
Este trabalho está licenciado sob uma licença Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
O envio de manuscrito para a revista garante aos seus autores a manutenção dos direitos autorais sobre o mesmo e autoriza que a revista realize a primeira publicação do texto. Os dados, conceitos e opiniões apresentados nos trabalhos, bem como a exatidão das referências documentais e bibliográficas, são de inteira responsabilidade dos autores.
Este obra está licenciada com uma Licença Creative Commons Atribuição 4.0 Internacional.
